Yoast SEO vs All In One SEO WordPress Plugin: The Ultimate Comparison

Given the wide range of options, it often becomes tough to choose the most relevant WordPress plugins. But, usually for search engines out of all the options, the filter is always narrowed down to either Yoast or All in One SEO.

This is because they are the most popular ones and address the requirements of many.

To clear up this confusion of who is better from these two, it is essential to compare Yoast vs All in One SEO. This will help in establishing rock-solid reasons to use the best one.

Yoast vs All in One SEO

A brief understanding and background

Both these options are amongst the most used plugins of all time and hence are widely popular. Additionally, depending upon the user’s level of comfort they also have a devout userbase.

In 2007, Steve Mortiboy and Michael Torbert created All in One SEO. Its worth was recognized quickly and therefore it became one of the most downloaded programs of all time.

In the year 2010, Yoast SEO was actually started as WordPress SEO by Yoast which was created by Joost de Valk. It underwent core changes and with constant improvements, it soon became a rival for All in One SEO.

Out of all other options in this industry, both these help you in getting the maximum benefit for your site. Moreover, in this read, we will compare a few aspects of both these options and analyze which one can be best for you.

So let’s begin this apt comparison of Yoast vs All in One SEO.

Installation and Setup

The successful implementation of the concepts of search engine optimization into websites takes a lot of practice and training.

It is essential that without any special skills a plugin should make it easy for beginners to set up the best practices of search engines.

In this section, we will analyze how these two options stack up against each other in terms of installing and basic settings.

Yoast SEO

The basic operation here will be to install and activate this program. The step-by-step installation process is mostly simple. After activation, the configuration wizard can be launched under General Tab from the Dashboard.

It will bring up a step-by-step wizard, to walk the user through the setup process. Hence, all users can start quickly without any complex jargon.

This is a powerful program and comes with a lot of options that need to be explored one by one. The settings page is clearly divided into pages where a particular page has a tab for respective settings.

Therefore, locating different options from the settings also becomes easy. You will also come across the Help button on all pages. It will help through textual content or video about different options on a particular page.

Overall the settings and configuration wizard is neat and makes it convenient for even beginners to set up.

All In One SEO

Just like every other program in the WordPress site this also needs installation and activation in the initial stage. It also adheres to a step-by-step installation process which is not much complicated.

After a successful installation, you will easily find its menu item just below the Dashboard. After clicking on it the users will be taken to the settings page.

All kinds of settings that need to be configured can be discovered on a single page. It might seem a little overwhelming when compared to its rival.

But, users across the globe have found this approach faster and easier compared to multipage settings of Option Y.

The settings page here is divided into different sections and each of them deals with peculiar areas. For example, title settings, homepage settings, display settings, etc.

Next to each option for assistance, you will also discover a help icon. A short description will appear when you click on the icon and a link to additional documentation will also appear.

Hence, the entire process becomes easier for beginners to start and understand the process.

You will have to explore the general settings and then you will be ready to use the program on your WordPress site.

Both these competitors have a lot of options to assist and help their users. With multiple offerings, the entire process might look a little intermediating from the outside.

But, at every level, both the programs ensure that things are simplified and the setup & installation is easy.

In this segment of comparison of Yoast vs All in One SEO, depending upon your preference you can decide a clear winner. It can be either a multipage options menu or a single-page menu option program.

Day to Day Search Engine Optimization Tasks

One of the most dynamic and ongoing processes is search engine optimization. Therefore, for all comparisons and specifically here for Yoast vs All in One SEO its evaluation is equally important.

Every time you add a new post or page to your site, it has a distinct optimization score for search engines. Hence, search results optimization is undoubtedly a key factor.

Apart from using these programs, there are also certain other methods that you can look for to optimize the performance.

We will have an overlook of how both these contenders perform these dedicated day-to-day tasks on your site, in this section.

Yoast SEO

To ensure that users can optimize all the posts and pages on the site, it offers a powerful content analysis tool.

Immediately below the post editor, you can detect the SEO meta box with a snippet preview, content analysis, and focus keyword field.

The appearance of your website’s title and description in search engines can be viewed from the snippet preview. It automatically uses post title and excerpt as title and decryption respectively.

It is highly recommended that you modify it by clicking on the edit button for better results.

Your content for a particular keyword can be analyzed by entering a focus keyword in the program. The analysis is displayed in the content analysis area along with suggestions on improving your search engine optimization score.

The meta box also comes with two more sections i.e. advanced view and social settings.

Unless you are a pro and know what you are doing, do not use the advanced view option. It has the potential to enable search engines for indexing or following a page/post.

The social settings enable you to set an article image for Twitter or Facebook. In the open graph meta tags, the program will automatically use the main title and description.

All In One SEO

Here in this option also for editing search engine optimization settings on a post-by-post basis, it comes with a similar meta box. The user simply needs to edit any post to find the specific meta box.

The entire process here is extremely simple compared to that of its competitor. Editing the title and description is also possible but unlike the other, search engine optimization scoring or content analysis is not possible.

When it comes to advanced tools here, there are some that enable control indexing and following by search engines.

Additionally, it also offers a feature that turns off the entire plugin for a particular page or post. You can also find a social feature here as well. All you have to do is visit the Features Manager page from the program.

Enabling it will add a social settings tab below the post editor on the meta box. Descriptions used by Twitter and Facebook along with custom images can be set with it.

From the above section, you would definitely be clear about the core difference in day-to-day tasks related to search engines. This comparison with the apt facts regarding Yoast vs All in One SEO is specifically for that.

One option allows you a lean and clean approach along with the provision of adding users as required. The other option offers a little subtle approach but provides features that are essential for the site.

Now depending upon the target audience and as per the features from this section of comparison of Yoast vs All in One SEO, you can select the best one for your site.

Additional Tools and Features

Apart from just meta tags, it becomes essential to include other additional tools and features that both this plugin offers. This will help you in deciding and making a better choice.

It will also aptly help you in figuring out the best one for you from the Yoast vs All in One SEO plugin.

By default, the presence of these features in these plugins eliminates the need to rely on different programs. Indirectly it is all about addressing the quest of discovering a true all-in-one solution.

Yoast SEO

To cover most of the aspects of on-site optimization this program comes with a comprehensive set of features. Some of these tools are:

  • Open Graph Meta Tags
  • XML Sitemaps
  • Breadcrumb Navigation
  • Importing Data from Google Webmaster tools
  • Import/Export SEO Data
  • Built-in robots.txt and .htaccess editor

All In One SEO

This plugin also has analyzed the need for various features that are demanded by the users. It has included most of it but the activation of the same has to be carried out manually.

The user needs to navigate to the Features Manager option from the program and then activate the required features. Some of its tools offerings include:

  • txt
  • Performance Manager
  • Bad Bot Blocker
  • Open Graph Meta Tags
  • Import and Export SEO Data
  • XML Sitemap
  • File Editor

The above comparison of tools section of Yoast vs All in One SEO clarifies multiple things. The important one being that the offerings are almost the same and the difference is limited.

You have to analyze what your website needs specifically according to the scale and functionality of your site. After that, it will become convenient to declare a clear winner in this section according to your requirements.

Related Post: Comparison of Yoast SEO vs Squirrly SEO Plugin vs WordPress SEO Ultimate

Support and Addons

This is an important section to consider that helps in setting the expectations right for the long term. Despite extensive free documentation, the free support is extremely limited.

Let’s explore and compare how Yoast Vs All in One SEO plugins handle professional support and addons.

Yoast SEO

The basic free version of this program comes with no specific support. This means that you can use it with all your knowledge and understanding.

Obtaining a solution from different support forums regarding the problems that you are facing can be a way out. But in no case, the users are guaranteed an official response from team Yoast.

If you intend to opt for professional support, then you can select Yoast SEO premium. For a single site license, the pricing is approximately $70. The pricing increases as more sites are added.

With the premium version, you also get hold of other features like multiple focus keywords and redirect manager.

It also offers some paid add-on plugins that are available exclusively for niche sites with specific SEO requirements. Some of these addon programs are:

  • Local SEO
  • News SEO
  • Video SEO

All In One SEO

The unpaid version of All one in One SEO also does not offer any support. It has a wide user base and frequent challenges can be tackled from resolutions through online support forums.
One year of professional support is offered with the Pro version of this plugin. The license costs approximately $100 per year.

The pro version is one of its major versions ahead of the free plugin. Additionally, it also comes with extra features like

  • Support for WooCommerce Products
  • Category SEO options
  • Video XML Sitemap

The pricing structure in this comparison plugins is clearly as per the above section. In terms of licensing and pricing the usage and requirements matter.

As you add sites for operation the prices will gradually increase. But for single sites depending upon the selection, you can select the best-priced plugin with the required features.

Final Conclusion
The comparison of the Yoast vs All in One SEO plugin ends here. Hence, we tried out best to comprehensively present to you the core differences.

We recommend that depending upon the specific requirements of your website you can make a wise selection. Take into consideration all factors and select one best program from the above two.

About Sonnal S Sinha

Sonnal S SinhaSonnal S Sinha is a passionate writer as well as WordPress and WooCommerce rockstar who loves to share insights on various topics through his engaging blog posts. He run successful website design and digital marketing company. With 15+ years of experience in WordPress themes development, he strives to inform and inspire readers with his thought-provoking content. He helps thousands small and medium businesses and startups create a unique online presence. Follow Sonnal S Sinha for your regular dose of knowledge and inspiration.